Development of policy for the effective management of natural resources
Table of contents: The Kazakh-American Free University Academic Journal №12 - 2020
Author: Muhammad Ishaq Safi, Kazakh-American Free University, Kazakhstan, Herat, Afghanistan
The defensive and
bearable use of land, water, air, forests, rangeland, flora and fauna constituting
the major part of natural resources for delivering magnificent services to the
ecosystem helping to uplift and ease human life by providing basic life support
in the form of consumptive and public-good services including soil
productivity, recycling of food, cleansing of air, provision of oxygen in the
long run is known as natural resources management [2].
In Asia during the
recent decades an increasing attention is diverted towards the management
issues of natural resource in response to food, water, energy and other resources
reduction crises due to overwhelming challenges faced by the environment because
of climate change, poverty, low productivity and ineffective resources mobilization
and management.
Countries in Asia are facing numerous environmental challenges as they have compromised their natural
resources base consumption for technological growth and advancement and this
has adversely effected and increased pressure on natural resources for
urbanization, infrastructure development, population growth, market demand and
international trade. Such settings and conditions have deteriorated the quality
and quantity of water, forest and land as the rehabilitation of these resources
are not guaranteed causes injustice use, disputes over shares and threats to
the feasibility and sustainability of natural resources in Asia. These combats
on the ownership and use of natural resources are ignited due to the
contrasting goals of the Government and community for the protection,
rehabilitation, over use, bargaining, timber trade, wood fuel, political unrest
and social values [1].
Natural resources
management in Afghanistan is a is a key cross-cutting issue that adds to the
impetus for improved awareness regarding policy and institutional analysis
impact to provide the community with the best of technical capability and
advising them on how to deal with future issues needs highly efficient policy
with predicted human factors.
Policies plays important
role and are vital element of any association and agency as it portrays
significance by addressing relevant and persistent problems like guiding the
behavior of employees in acceptable manner for decision making consistency.
The innovation concepts in recent years has gone up but still there is need for
policy choices to be adopted by the government as thoughtful classification of
values for achieving coherent deliverables based on good practices, and
knowledge management to strengthen the effective management of natural
resources in Afghanistan.
Forests, rangelands, protected
areas and wildlife forms the natural Resources of Afghanistan are under immense
pressure through man-made and natural disasters including population rise,
poverty, overdependence of rural populations low level of awareness, climate
change and no existing policy are the biggest challenges for the protection and
management of natural resources while supplementing three quarter of population
livelihoods (GD-NRM strategy, 2017) [5].
Oli 2013, stated that Afghanistan has some of the world's most advance, pioneering regulations and guidelines of
natural resources management on forestry, water and wildlife management but
these policies are having little perceptible effect as the provinces have
slight administrative capacity to put them into action on the ground [6].
Shrestha and Thapa,
2019, reviewed policies and programs in South Asian countries and identified
that piloting and scaling-up of sustainable climate resilience and natural
resource management is the highest priority [8].
UNEP 2009 reported that
there is a lack of laws and policies in Afghanistan to facilitate the
implementation of natural resources management through combating desertification,
drought, biodiversity conservation and climate change and are rarely considered
in the processes of plans, sector policies, investment plans and national
legislation [7].
The goal of this
research is to identify policy areas for the effective management of natural
resources by reviewing and evaluating different policy formulation models and
design implementation options to assist and guide organization in making plans
and decisions. A survey of 72 employees of the General Directorate of natural
resources management were conducted to study the perception, use,
implementation, importance, behavior and performance standards regarding
development of NRM policy.
Fifty six percent of the
natural resources policy formulation and design survey respondents reported
that population pressure, poor economy and land lords have weakened the
traditional strategies for coping and management of natural resources. Majority
of the participants emphasized that policies are the backbone for resources
management in controlling decisions and must be developed within the present
context as an organization without policy is an organization without control.
Most of the natural
resources managers revealed that policy being essential part of an organization
administration to cope with related issues and guidance while decision making
clearly defining the classification of stages to be followed in a consistent manner
showing the limitation and responses to policy violations. Sixty five percent
of the respondents reported that they are using policies when needed, while
thirty and five percent of the respondents concluded that they used policies
during daily activities and not et al as well respectively.
Establishing green
landscape and natural resources dependent efficient economy is a centric
contest of development in Afghanistan today as 91% of the natural resources
users are of the view that putting policy in place to reduce logging,
deforestation desertification and promote sustainability will boost
organization performance efficiency and improve resources productivity can help
in enhancing the environment to bring down the resources over use for human
economic growth, insecurity and competitiveness. Furthermore, this assessment
portrayed that management of natural resources resource efficiency is highly
dependent on national policy based on collective action and coordinated inputs
to ensure equal assistances in Afghanistan.
Development of new
policy for the management of natural resources in Afghanistan plays a necessary
role in highlighting the best sectoral practices in establishing a platform for
exchanging experiences at national and international level. The key message of
95% interview informants of NRM policy formulation assessment is that the new
policy should target the resources efficiency in terms of products entire
life-cycle and more emphases on making parallel and integrated sectoral
policies in various areas including novelty, venture, trade, education and
services development with natural resource management efficiency aims. NRM
sustainability requires uprising by merging management policies
However, these policies
and procedures are rendered useless if employers neglect to adhere to them or
fail to effectively communicate them to employees. Utilizing both policies and
procedures during decision-making ensures that employers are consistent in
their decisions.
Natural resources
require related policies merging for sustainability and management to execute
over extensive productive sectors by involving multiple users and institutions
proficient in dealing with the swiftly growing petition for natural resources,
are critical for effective implementation of well-organized, reasonable and
justifiable resource use claimed by 75% of the policy assessment pretenders.
Here the results show that the new NRM policy should have fluctuating groupings
of state, cooperative action and discrete ownership rights.
Sixty two percent of the
NRM policy development options survey contestant investigation agreed that
policy promote exchanges, collective learning, and information sharing are
instrumental for handling opposition and shortage of resources. This will
improve the effectiveness and impartiality of resources allocation and helps in
wanted constitutional rights to natural resources tempt users to deliberate the
full cost and alternative uses value. Also, the result and problem solving
oriented policy will allow for efficient and equitable use of resources among
the deprived local inhabitants, native groups, womenfolk and youth to access
and secure their rights.
Policy and technology
are two separate worlds and there is a gap between them identifies in the year
1959 known as the two cultures of science and humanity hindering in solving the
world's problem. We must bridge the gap between technology and policymaking as
our future depends on it; [3]. In case of Afghanistan NRM sector drivers as per
the investigation eight percent believe that in this modern era of technology
there is still need for policy choices because it helps in thoughtful
classification of values while seven percent stresses that policy helps in
achieving coherent deliverables. Amon them the rest eighty five percent
suggests that in this technological era of science policy is of utmost
importance as it supports in considerate organization of morals aids in accomplishing
comprehensible outcomes.
Natural resources Policy
development is based on good practices and knowledge management to strengthen
the effective management of natural resources in Afghanistan, adds to the
impetus for improved awareness of resources and also advise managers and
community in how to deal with constraints exposed by eighty nine percent of
this investigation contributors. While seven percent of the survey contributors
said that policy reinforce the operative supervision of natural resources. the
remaining four percent are of the view that policy improves the motivation for
better outreach of resources.
Policy gap analysis is
required in management aspects of natural resources of Afghanistan to find out how does management impacts performance and formulate or amend new policy
for efficient organization management. Gap analysis is used to make the
negotiation and progress more planned as it identifies how rationalized and how
tenable current policies are, address present glitches so that future action
plans can be effective when it comes to providing the needs of the business
[4].
This study showed that
causes of rarely used developed policies are problem between top management
& employees and poor policy implementation. The NRM policy formulation and
design respondents reported that as per their experience throughout policy
making process sometime times the leading agency fails to to gain their main
objective of securing authoritative status for certain policies implementation.
The other reason for rarely used policy is that Government is unable to form a
policy and mix it with a program just to avoid conflict of policy failure. Most
of the times the specific objectives of a policy are not well translated into
actions to overcome implementation performance because of theoretical
sophistications.
Weaknesses in policy
implementation in Afghanistan are lack of capacities in provincial and local
level employees caused the rare implementation of NRM policy in the field are
still not clear at central level as well. This needs specific policies for technical
decision making as policies are not well coordinated and communicated to provincial
and field level staff and a living example is NRM strategy. Policy maker should
be a think thought group having a deep study of the consequences and able to
present a flexible and alternatives options for decision making. Policy
capability focuses on administrative and organizational skills with sound
research and analysis to support policy decisions and promote operational
performance policy implementation.
Low capacity is the main
reason of weakness in policy implementation with inadequate human and material
resources as the knowledge capacity of the top managers are not up to the mark
to understand and implement a specific policy. Unawareness of modern policy
making tools and knowledge and how does the new technology impacts policy
making process are the main reasons of poor policy making. Why policy do not
work out in Afghanistan is because corruption means that the top level
management advertently puts obstacles in front of policies to benefit a
specific group.
It is true that
technological skills are required to promote health policy changes but they are
not enough. Instead, they need to be complemented by civic involvement and
lobbying to ensure public interest that policies are intended to represent.
Corruption, lack of continuity in government policies, inadequate human and
material resources, all of which often lead to implementation gap, i.e. the
widening of the distance between stated policy goals and the realization of
such planned goals.
Policy development for
the effective management of natural resources requires reviewing and evaluating
different policy formulations models and design implementation options as there
is an intense need for natural resources policy of Long term and short term.
The study suggests the following characteristics and composition of for the New
NRM policy:
- The new policy should
reflect increase in public awareness regarding the outcomes of natural
resources management to support, strengthen and up-scale indigenous local
organizations, resume cooperatives and development;
- Transparency and
corruption free policy must be formulated as to eradicate poverty and uplift
the livelihoods of natural resources dependent rural communities depends;
- Policy must be based
on stakeholder analysis and approaches including wildlife conservation,
rangeland management, forests, water, air, biodiversity conservation and
geographical indicators to guide all partners at all level (decision makers,
practitioners, academia, donors);
- Policy should be based
on SWOT analysis to reflect sustainability, risks, improvement, conflict
resolution and accords of constitution to be strictly followed;
- It should be short,
medium- & long-term policy meeting the actual condition of Afghanistan made by national experts;
- The tools required for
natural resources management should be focused;
- Policy should reflect
the rights and responsibilities of individuals and communities in an action
plan;
- Policy should be in
local languages and practical.
It must have the options
for increasing the level of revenue and funding with specific goals objectives
and field of actions to collaborate with other relevant organizations in
climate resilience agriculture practices adaptation based on integrated management
approach;
- It should have
capacity building options;
- Policy should reflect
Government and donor commitment for economic values considerations, risks and
roadmap;
- Good governance,
accountability and integrated natural resource management;
- The policy should
address the main causes of national resources and gives clues regarding
approaches;
- The NRM policy should
follow an eco-friendly sustainable way to helped both current and future
conditions;
- Monitoring and
evaluation in the part of low capacity and especially in the part of
corruption;
- Revenue sharing
(between communities and government) which leads us to sustainable NRM;
- On ground action,
activities and responsibilities of both government and public;
- Role of private sector
and public private partnerships;
- NRM policy's
non-confirming programs and projects implement shall not be allowed;
- Implementation and
sustainability plan;
- To the NRM policy
these should be add Drought Food aid Decreasing size of cultivable land.
REFERENCES
1. Meinzen-Dick R., in Redefining Diversity
& Dynamics of Natural Resources Management in Asia, Volume 1, 2017.
2. Iyyanki V. Muralikrishna, Valli Manickam, in
Environmental Management, 2017
3. We Must Bridge the Gap between Technology and
Policymaking. Our Future Depends On It. URL:
https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2019/11/we-must-bridge-the-gap-between-technology-and-policy-our-future-depends-on-it/
4. 9+ Policy Gap Analysis Examples. URL: https://www.examples. com/ business/ policy-gap-analysis-examples.html
5. Allan McConnell; why do policies fail? A
starting point for exploration. Paper presented at political Studies Association
64th Annual International Conference 14-16 April 2014, Manchester.
6. Afghanistan Drought Risk management Strategy
2019- 2030; Food and Agriculture Organization and Ministry of Agriculture,
Irrigation and Livestock Afghanistan.
7. Oli Brown, 2013, Encouraging Peace-building
through Better Environmental and Natural Resource Management;
8. United Nation Environment Protection, 2009,
National Capacity Needs Self-Assessment for Global Environmental Management and
National Adaptation Program of Action for Climate Change;
9. Shrestha and Thapa, 2019; Policy and Program
Priorities in Agricultural Research & Development in South Asia
Table of contents: The Kazakh-American Free University Academic Journal №12 - 2020
|